Who are the top head-to-head performers?

Back to Excruciating Baseball Lists
Overall Records
Players born in
1923 1924 1925 1926 1927 1928 1929
1930 1931 1932 1933 1934 1935 1936 1937 1938 1939
1940 1941 1942 1943 1944 1945 1946 1947 1948 1949
1950 1951 1952 1953 1954 1955 1956 1957 1958 1959
1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969
1970 1971 1972 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979
1980 1981
Players whose last name starts with
  A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W Y Z

Players born in 1932

Don Blasingame (1955-1966)
RackedSkunkedHigh OPSLow OPS
H: 39 (124) R. Roberts
XBH: 10 (123) B. Friend
1B: 32 (124) R. Roberts
2B: 6 (123) B. Friend
3B: 4 (117) W. Spahn
HR: 2 (33) P. Regan
RBI: 11 (59) J. Nuxhall
BB: 12 (56) D. Cardwell
SO: 13 (79) H. Haddix
HBP: 2 (42) J. Pizarro
H: 0 (15) D. Boswell
XBH: 0 (56) D. Cardwell
1B: 0 (15) D. Boswell
2B: 0 (79) H. Haddix
3B: 0 (87) J. Sanford
HR: 0 (120) L. Burdette
RBI: 0 (61) S. Williams
BB: 0 (40) W. Bunker
BB: 0 (40) B. Monbouquette
SO: 0 (44) H. Jeffcoat
HBP: 0 (124) R. Roberts
0.964 (36) B. Gibson
0.932 (31) J. Brosnan
0.901 (43) J. Owens
0.899 (36) J. Hook
0.885 (72) J. Antonelli
0.879 (33) P. Regan
0.837 (30) M. Grant
0.815 (44) H. Jeffcoat
0.802 (59) J. Nuxhall
0.796 (33) O. Pena
0.529 (89) J. Podres
0.525 (40) W. Bunker
0.508 (57) B. Anderson
0.492 (44) A. Mahaffey
0.486 (35) C. Pascual
0.418 (42) D. Gross
0.409 (79) H. Haddix
0.404 (36) T. Farrell
0.331 (31) C. Labine
0.331 (31) D. Chance

Eddie Bressoud (1956-1967)
RackedSkunkedHigh OPSLow OPS
H: 16 (43) M. Grant
XBH: 9 (42) J. Bouton
1B: 10 (40) W. Ford
2B: 6 (43) M. Grant
3B: 3 (36) C. Osteen
HR: 4 (55) H. Haddix
RBI: 8 (55) H. Haddix
BB: 8 (43) M. Grant
SO: 16 (36) J. Bunning
HBP: 1 (5) J. Fisher
H: 0 (8) C. Labine
H: 0 (8) R. Piche
H: 0 (8) T. Poholsky
XBH: 0 (25) C. Estrada
XBH: 0 (25) J. Podres
XBH: 0 (25) R. Sheldon
1B: 0 (17) J. Brosnan
2B: 0 (35) M. Pappas
3B: 0 (85) R. Roberts
HR: 0 (85) R. Roberts
RBI: 0 (46) D. Chance
BB: 0 (55) H. Haddix
SO: 0 (19) C. Simmons
HBP: 0 (85) R. Roberts
1.444 (43) M. Grant
1.313 (39) R. Terry
1.268 (42) J. Bouton
1.095 (36) C. Osteen
1.034 (40) P. Regan
0.986 (31) B. Daniels
0.985 (30) S. Barber
0.962 (36) D. Wickersham
0.902 (35) P. Ramos
0.891 (42) B. Latman
0.639 (42) V. Mizell
0.636 (39) V. Law
0.631 (35) L. Stange
0.611 (36) D. Segui
0.565 (43) J. Pizarro
0.499 (32) O. Pena
0.479 (85) R. Roberts
0.465 (36) J. Bunning
0.456 (46) D. Chance
0.353 (35) B. Friend

Bud Daley (1955-1964)
RackedSkunkedHigh OPSLow OPS
H: 24 (85) N. Fox
XBH: 8 (50) R. Colavito
1B: 22 (85) N. Fox
2B: 6 (53) B. Skowron
3B: 2 (85) N. Fox
HR: 7 (50) R. Colavito
RBI: 14 (64) M. Minoso
BB: 11 (65) G. Triandos
SO: 10 (25) C. Maxwell
HBP: 6 (64) M. Minoso
H: 0 (12) D. Nicholson
XBH: 0 (30) J. Busby
1B: 0 (18) B. Johnson
2B: 0 (85) N. Fox
3B: 0 (65) W. Tasby
3B: 0 (65) G. Triandos
HR: 0 (85) N. Fox
RBI: 0 (32) R. Sievers
BB: 0 (43) J. Piersall
SO: 0 (51) B. Phillips
HBP: 0 (65) W. Tasby
HBP: 0 (65) G. Triandos
1.334 (30) C. Boyer
1.241 (50) R. Colavito
1.224 (31) T. Williams
1.184 (47) E. Yost
1.179 (49) A. Kaline
1.097 (53) B. Skowron
1.092 (30) B. Nieman
1.037 (38) W. Dropo
1.025 (37) J. Romano
1.019 (64) M. Minoso
0.581 (35) G. Geiger
0.576 (65) W. Tasby
0.575 (39) B. Richardson
0.575 (32) R. Sievers
0.540 (48) V. Power
0.521 (51) B. Phillips
0.515 (35) B. Gardner
0.505 (50) S. Lollar
0.464 (51) T. Kubek
0.451 (36) G. Woodling

Bennie Daniels (1957-1965)
RackedSkunkedHigh OPSLow OPS
H: 17 (54) R. Colavito
XBH: 12 (54) R. Colavito
1B: 15 (44) V. Power
2B: 6 (54) R. Colavito
3B: 2 (20) D. Buford
HR: 6 (54) R. Colavito
RBI: 16 (54) R. Colavito
BB: 8 (52) N. Cash
SO: 9 (42) C. Boyer
HBP: 1 (3) S. Hemus
H: 0 (12) D. Nicholson
XBH: 0 (42) C. Boyer
1B: 0 (17) A. Smith
2B: 0 (57) B. Bruton
3B: 0 (54) R. Colavito
HR: 0 (44) J. Lumpe
HR: 0 (44) V. Power
RBI: 0 (31) C. Fernandez
BB: 0 (35) M. Mantle
SO: 0 (51) F. Robinson
HBP: 0 (57) B. Bruton
1.243 (54) R. Colavito
1.191 (34) J. Gentile
1.086 (35) M. Mantle
1.061 (32) E. Battey
1.037 (52) N. Cash
1.034 (53) N. Siebern
1.029 (37) C. Yastrzemski
0.986 (31) E. Bressoud
0.954 (39) B. Robinson
0.936 (39) R. Maris
0.551 (36) L. Green
0.521 (31) L. Thomas
0.520 (38) D. Howser
0.502 (42) C. Boyer
0.471 (44) J. Lumpe
0.452 (43) W. Kirkland
0.408 (31) C. Fernandez
0.406 (31) E. Charles
0.288 (38) L. Aparicio
0.240 (30) B. Skowron

Mike Fornieles (1952-1963)
RackedSkunkedHigh OPSLow OPS
H: 25 (74) H. Kuenn
XBH: 10 (74) H. Kuenn
1B: 18 (53) N. Fox
2B: 8 (74) H. Kuenn
3B: 2 (41) D. Philley
HR: 5 (38) H. Killebrew
RBI: 12 (38) H. Killebrew
BB: 8 (40) F. Bolling
SO: 12 (41) M. Mantle
HBP: 3 (34) W. Held
H: 0 (12) E. McGhee
XBH: 0 (24) B. Boyd
XBH: 0 (24) Z. Versalles
1B: 0 (23) G. Stephens
2B: 0 (55) R. Boone
3B: 0 (67) A. Kaline
HR: 0 (55) R. Boone
HR: 0 (55) B. Goodman
RBI: 0 (35) B. Avila
BB: 0 (33) B. Phillips
SO: 0 (53) N. Fox
HBP: 0 (74) H. Kuenn
1.197 (38) H. Killebrew
1.127 (34) B. Martin
1.118 (41) G. Triandos
1.037 (41) G. Woodling
1.029 (42) M. Minoso
0.997 (33) E. Battey
0.978 (74) H. Kuenn
0.977 (33) B. Phillips
0.960 (34) W. Held
0.960 (46) C. Maxwell
0.668 (53) E. Yost
0.659 (32) J. Jensen
0.595 (38) H. Lopez
0.572 (33) J. Busby
0.569 (30) B. Allison
0.560 (41) B. Gardner
0.536 (38) A. Pilarcik
0.532 (55) R. Boone
0.469 (43) B. Nieman
0.392 (48) L. Aparicio

Woodie Held (1954-1969)
RackedSkunkedHigh OPSLow OPS
H: 22 (97) M. Pappas
XBH: 8 (97) M. Pappas
1B: 14 (68) R. Terry
2B: 4 (54) S. Barber
3B: 2 (30) T. Sturdivant
HR: 5 (42) T. Brewer
RBI: 14 (42) T. Brewer
BB: 11 (76) E. Wynn
SO: 20 (97) M. Pappas
HBP: 4 (36) B. Turley
H: 0 (17) R. Duren
H: 0 (17) S. Hamilton
XBH: 0 (34) J. Walker
1B: 0 (33) H. Wilhelm
2B: 0 (68) P. Foytack
3B: 0 (97) M. Pappas
HR: 0 (71) W. Ford
RBI: 0 (71) W. Ford
BB: 0 (34) I. Delock
SO: 0 (17) M. Kutyna
HBP: 0 (97) M. Pappas
1.257 (42) H. Aguirre
1.091 (31) D. Larsen
1.014 (51) H. Brown
1.008 (41) B. Daley
0.984 (35) D. Maas
0.960 (34) M. Fornieles
0.924 (56) C. Pascual
0.908 (44) B. Fischer
0.901 (42) T. Brewer
0.892 (63) P. Ramos
0.592 (59) B. Monbouquette
0.573 (33) B. Shaw
0.561 (71) W. Ford
0.543 (41) D. Donovan
0.527 (55) B. Pierce
0.498 (63) J. Bunning
0.489 (31) S. McDowell
0.427 (31) D. Chance
0.418 (33) H. Wilhelm
0.275 (34) J. Walker

Billy Hoeft (1952-1966)
RackedSkunkedHigh OPSLow OPS
H: 42 (141) M. Mantle
XBH: 15 (123) M. Minoso
1B: 29 (141) M. Mantle
2B: 7 (69) L. Aparicio
3B: 4 (69) L. Aparicio
HR: 8 (93) R. Sievers
RBI: 21 (123) M. Minoso
BB: 23 (141) M. Mantle
SO: 24 (141) M. Mantle
HBP: 3 (153) N. Fox
H: 0 (15) P. Suder
XBH: 0 (64) J. Hegan
1B: 0 (15) P. Suder
2B: 0 (96) C. Carrasquel
3B: 0 (108) E. Yost
HR: 0 (80) P. Runnels
RBI: 0 (47) J. DeMaestri
BB: 0 (35) J. Finigan
SO: 0 (21) I. Noren
HBP: 0 (141) M. Mantle
1.448 (32) E. Robinson
1.181 (37) S. Mele
1.124 (44) J. Lemon
1.110 (48) S. White
1.067 (123) M. Minoso
1.059 (141) M. Mantle
1.044 (69) J. Piersall
1.042 (37) D. Philley
1.032 (59) R. Colavito
1.020 (93) R. Sievers
0.526 (62) G. Triandos
0.501 (49) V. Power
0.501 (53) P. Rizzuto
0.483 (96) C. Carrasquel
0.448 (57) B. Gardner
0.423 (103) Y. Berra
0.416 (33) T. Francona
0.414 (52) B. Goodman
0.387 (30) A. Pearson
0.260 (64) J. Hegan

Eddie Kasko (1957-1966)
RackedSkunkedHigh OPSLow OPS
H: 22 (78) M. McCormick
XBH: 6 (71) E. Broglio
1B: 19 (81) L. Burdette
2B: 6 (71) E. Broglio
3B: 1 (5) C. Olivo
HR: 2 (19) J. Owens
RBI: 7 (37) S. Williams
BB: 11 (62) R. Sadecki
SO: 12 (58) B. Gibson
HBP: 2 (35) S. Miller
HBP: 2 (35) C. Willey
H: 0 (8) C. McLish
XBH: 0 (81) L. Burdette
1B: 0 (19) J. Brewer
2B: 0 (81) L. Burdette
3B: 0 (84) W. Spahn
HR: 0 (84) W. Spahn
RBI: 0 (78) M. McCormick
BB: 0 (32) A. Mahaffey
SO: 0 (37) S. Williams
HBP: 0 (84) W. Spahn
0.967 (34) M. Drabowsky
0.881 (42) A. Jackson
0.856 (36) L. McDaniel
0.846 (37) S. Williams
0.837 (71) E. Broglio
0.833 (31) B. Buhl
0.825 (48) D. Ellsworth
0.822 (78) M. McCormick
0.740 (40) R. Kline
0.731 (38) B. O'Dell
0.543 (65) V. Law
0.536 (84) W. Spahn
0.532 (31) G. Conley
0.518 (56) J. Marichal
0.489 (75) J. Sanford
0.486 (72) D. Drysdale
0.484 (81) L. Burdette
0.453 (39) J. Antonelli
0.382 (49) R. Craig
0.330 (37) R. Roberts

Ron Kline (1952-1970)
RackedSkunkedHigh OPSLow OPS
H: 28 (104) D. Snider
XBH: 14 (104) D. Snider
1B: 22 (87) R. Ashburn
2B: 7 (41) W. Kirkland
3B: 3 (38) J. Roseboro
HR: 7 (77) H. Aaron
RBI: 21 (104) D. Snider
BB: 16 (104) D. Snider
SO: 13 (49) J. Adcock
HBP: 2 (19) S. Hemus
H: 0 (14) V. Thomas
XBH: 0 (51) C. Furillo
1B: 0 (26) D. Stuart
2B: 0 (51) C. Furillo
3B: 0 (87) R. Ashburn
HR: 0 (87) R. Ashburn
RBI: 0 (28) L. Walls
BB: 0 (35) B. Richardson
SO: 0 (59) S. Musial
HBP: 0 (104) D. Snider
1.253 (42) D. Crandall
1.244 (58) E. Banks
1.209 (43) E. Bailey
1.171 (77) H. Aaron
1.137 (33) B. Allison
1.104 (30) H. Sauer
1.104 (34) V. Pinson
1.100 (40) R. Campanella
1.098 (104) D. Snider
1.095 (49) S. Burgess
0.549 (39) E. Bouchee
0.541 (62) J. Logan
0.537 (49) H. Anderson
0.537 (44) O. Cepeda
0.535 (46) D. Zimmer
0.515 (32) Z. Versalles
0.495 (62) A. Dark
0.471 (35) H. Landrith
0.394 (51) C. Furillo
0.385 (33) C. Fernandez

Johnny Podres (1953-1969)
RackedSkunkedHigh OPSLow OPS
H: 47 (121) R. Clemente
XBH: 20 (125) W. Mays
1B: 39 (121) R. Clemente
2B: 9 (125) W. Mays
3B: 2 (4) M. Ranew
HR: 10 (125) W. Mays
RBI: 23 (128) W. Post
BB: 24 (125) W. Mays
SO: 23 (123) F. Robinson
HBP: 2 (73) J. Davenport
H: 0 (17) D. Menke
XBH: 0 (40) G. Cimoli
XBH: 0 (40) D. Mueller
1B: 0 (18) D. Cole
1B: 0 (18) C. Dalrymple
2B: 0 (56) H. Smith
3B: 0 (123) F. Robinson
HR: 0 (90) R. Ashburn
RBI: 0 (32) L. Jackson
BB: 0 (87) B. Virdon
SO: 0 (40) D. Mueller
HBP: 0 (148) K. Boyer
1.441 (31) G. Green
1.242 (125) W. Mays
1.133 (39) L. Walls
1.090 (52) T. Kluszewski
1.078 (50) R. Santo
1.048 (46) L. Cardenas
1.037 (123) F. Robinson
1.026 (38) R. Mejias
1.007 (40) G. Hamner
1.006 (99) H. Aaron
0.534 (88) G. Bell
0.534 (67) D. Spencer
0.529 (89) D. Blasingame
0.525 (64) J. Adcock
0.486 (87) B. Virdon
0.473 (40) G. Cimoli
0.461 (40) D. Mueller
0.455 (44) C. James
0.447 (40) R. Amaro
0.267 (32) L. Jackson

Dick Stuart (1958-1969)
RackedSkunkedHigh OPSLow OPS
H: 21 (88) W. Spahn
XBH: 9 (53) C. Simmons
1B: 14 (88) W. Spahn
2B: 6 (53) C. Simmons
3B: 3 (41) C. Osteen
HR: 5 (49) D. Cardwell
RBI: 15 (64) D. Drysdale
BB: 8 (43) B. Purkey
SO: 23 (64) R. Roberts
HBP: 2 (7) P. Mikkelsen
H: 0 (15) C. Koonce
XBH: 0 (30) O. Pena
1B: 0 (26) R. Kline
2B: 0 (61) J. O'Toole
3B: 0 (69) S. Koufax
HR: 0 (55) J. Buzhardt
RBI: 0 (25) B. Veale
BB: 0 (49) D. Cardwell
SO: 0 (15) A. Gatewood
HBP: 0 (88) W. Spahn
1.234 (34) J. Antonelli
1.175 (38) J. Sanford
1.134 (53) C. Simmons
1.069 (45) R. Sadecki
1.027 (33) L. McDaniel
0.996 (41) C. Osteen
0.988 (35) B. Anderson
0.941 (68) S. Williams
0.940 (74) J. Podres
0.937 (45) G. Hobbie
0.739 (40) E. Broglio
0.733 (33) T. Farrell
0.705 (40) L. Jackson
0.669 (88) W. Spahn
0.637 (55) J. Buzhardt
0.633 (41) B. Buhl
0.541 (31) R. Craig
0.473 (64) R. Roberts
0.424 (37) B. O'Dell
0.343 (30) O. Pena

Maury Wills (1959-1972)
RackedSkunkedHigh OPSLow OPS
H: 57 (185) J. Marichal
XBH: 9 (115) D. Lemaster
1B: 54 (185) J. Marichal
2B: 7 (129) C. Short
3B: 2 (17) K. MacKenzie
HR: 2 (89) R. Sadecki
RBI: 8 (87) M. McCormick
BB: 13 (107) J. Jay
SO: 18 (82) J. O'Toole
HBP: 1 (6) B. Kelso
H: 0 (11) G. Wagner
XBH: 0 (72) J. Sanford
1B: 0 (15) F. Sullivan
2B: 0 (100) B. Buhl
3B: 0 (141) L. Jackson
HR: 0 (185) J. Marichal
RBI: 0 (50) W. Fryman
BB: 0 (63) K. Johnson
SO: 0 (32) R. Taylor
HBP: 0 (185) J. Marichal
0.927 (49) N. Briles
0.888 (31) F. Linzy
0.883 (30) E. Francis
0.878 (49) B. Bolin
0.876 (67) T. Cloninger
0.875 (41) J. Owens
0.870 (43) D. Giusti
0.869 (51) J. Niekro
0.848 (30) R. Herbel
0.841 (77) J. Gibbon
0.468 (72) J. Sanford
0.464 (95) C. Simmons
0.449 (75) B. Veale
0.406 (33) D. Roberts
0.400 (33) B. Sadowski
0.399 (36) D. Sutton
0.332 (50) W. Fryman
0.294 (49) K. Holtzman
0.274 (30) L. McDaniel
0.240 (30) G. Arrigo

Hal Woodeshick (1956-1967)
RackedSkunkedHigh OPSLow OPS
H: 12 (33) B. Tuttle
XBH: 6 (30) R. Sievers
1B: 10 (24) B. Wine
2B: 4 (24) F. Robinson
3B: 1 (4) G. Green
HR: 3 (31) M. Mantle
RBI: 9 (30) R. Sievers
BB: 8 (28) R. Clemente
SO: 11 (27) J. Callison
HBP: 2 (13) G. Alley
H: 0 (9) C. Dalrymple
H: 0 (9) T. Davis
H: 0 (9) W. Tasby
XBH: 0 (36) R. Santo
1B: 0 (17) N. Fox
2B: 0 (41) B. Williams
3B: 0 (36) R. Santo
HR: 0 (36) R. Santo
RBI: 0 (24) A. Rodgers
BB: 0 (29) B. White
SO: 0 (30) H. Kuenn
SO: 0 (30) R. Sievers
HBP: 0 (41) B. Williams
1.160 (30) R. Sievers
1.066 (31) M. Mantle
0.921 (33) B. Tuttle
0.915 (31) T. Taylor
0.858 (30) H. Kuenn
0.827 (31) B. Cerv
0.818 (30) N. Siebern
0.808 (34) L. Cardenas
0.761 (33) F. Bolling
0.758 (41) B. Williams
0.704 (31) R. Maris
0.513 (36) R. Santo
0.335 (34) V. Pinson

Plate appearances shown in parentheses.
Racked: Against which opponent did this player rack up the highest total in the indicated category? Ties are broken in order of fewest plate appearances.
Skunked: Which opponent did this player face the most times without ever registering in the indicated category?
High or Low OPS: Against which 10 opponents did this player compile the highest (or lowest) sum of on-base percentage and slugging average, with a minimum of 30 plate appearances?
Players are included if they totaled at least 3500 plate appearances or batters faced during the seasons listed below.
Includes all games played between 1974 and 2010, and almost all games played between 1950 and 1973. Can you help? The figures shown may not reflect the entire career of either the batter or the pitcher. In all probability, the rankings will change as additional games and seasons are released by Retrosheet. This page is presented for entertainment purposes only. Excruciating Baseball Lists accepts no responsibility for any disputes which may arise in response to any trivia questions posed based on information listed hereon.
The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at "www.retrosheet.org".