Who are the top head-to-head performers?

Players born in 1933

Ted Abernathy (1955-1972)
Racked	Skunked	High OPS	Low OPS
H: 10 (29) J. Callison XBH: 6 (19) T. Williams 1B: 8 (29) J. Callison 2B: 4 (23) W. Parker 3B: 3 (13) H. Simpson HR: 3 (29) W. Mays RBI: 8 (19) T. Williams BB: 9 (28) W. McCovey SO: 9 (27) J. Javier HBP: 2 (5) M. Epstein	H: 0 (14) K. Boyer XBH: 0 (28) B. Mazeroski 1B: 0 (22) C. Rojas 2B: 0 (29) W. Mays 3B: 0 (31) T. McCarver HR: 0 (34) A. Kaline RBI: 0 (27) T. Haller BB: 0 (30) F. Alou SO: 0 (31) T. McCarver HBP: 0 (34) A. Kaline	0.645 (34) A. Kaline	0.610 (30) F. Alou 0.540 (31) T. McCarver

Bob Bruce (1959-1967)
Racked	Skunked	High OPS	Low OPS
H: 19 (46) T. Gonzalez XBH: 8 (46) T. Gonzalez 1B: 16 (65) M. Wills 2B: 5 (30) W. Parker 3B: 2 (24) B. Skinner HR: 3 (44) J. Edwards HR: 3 (44) E. Mathews HR: 3 (44) R. Santo RBI: 12 (54) J. Roseboro BB: 10 (42) W. McCovey SO: 11 (38) T. Haller HBP: 3 (33) O. Cepeda	H: 0 (14) D. Ellsworth XBH: 0 (44) H. Aaron 1B: 0 (14) D. Ellsworth 1B: 0 (14) P. Runnels 2B: 0 (44) H. Aaron 3B: 0 (61) R. Fairly HR: 0 (65) M. Wills RBI: 0 (26) J. Pagan BB: 0 (36) J. Javier SO: 0 (20) B. Wine HBP: 0 (61) R. Fairly	1.207 (46) T. Gonzalez 1.164 (30) F. Alou 1.098 (30) W. Parker 1.082 (44) J. Edwards 1.020 (44) E. Mathews 1.000 (54) J. Roseboro 0.989 (40) B. Virdon 0.981 (37) F. Robinson 0.974 (38) W. Covington 0.973 (44) R. Santo	0.633 (42) C. Dalrymple 0.598 (58) W. Davis 0.595 (33) D. Clendenon 0.594 (37) D. Schofield 0.509 (36) G. Coleman 0.506 (44) D. Groat 0.425 (44) H. Aaron 0.413 (32) T. McCarver 0.372 (43) B. Bailey 0.242 (40) C. Hiller

Ed Charles (1962-1969)
Racked	Skunked	High OPS	Low OPS
H: 18 (75) C. Osteen XBH: 9 (75) C. Osteen 1B: 12 (61) E. Wilson 2B: 6 (75) C. Osteen 3B: 2 (19) M. Lopez HR: 3 (22) K. Holtzman RBI: 9 (28) J. Horlen BB: 10 (75) C. Osteen SO: 11 (58) W. Ford HBP: 2 (37) J. Buzhardt	H: 0 (12) E. Wynn XBH: 0 (43) A. Downing 1B: 0 (13) D. Hughes 2B: 0 (43) A. Downing 3B: 0 (61) G. Peters HR: 0 (58) M. McCormick RBI: 0 (25) E. Fisher RBI: 0 (25) D. Mossi BB: 0 (35) P. Ramos SO: 0 (22) D. McNally HBP: 0 (75) C. Osteen	1.325 (30) B. Veale 1.066 (35) M. Lolich 1.005 (36) P. Regan 0.910 (61) E. Wilson 0.870 (45) D. Chance 0.866 (75) C. Osteen 0.862 (58) W. Ford 0.853 (40) R. Terry 0.850 (55) S. Barber 0.766 (42) J. Kaat	0.641 (62) C. Pascual 0.635 (40) J. Bouton 0.634 (40) J. Perry 0.601 (58) M. McCormick 0.580 (42) R. Roberts 0.556 (35) P. Ramos 0.555 (43) S. McDowell 0.467 (32) B. Latman 0.408 (43) A. Downing 0.406 (31) B. Daniels

Rocky Colavito (1955-1968)
Racked	Skunked	High OPS	Low OPS
H: 30 (113) P. Ramos XBH: 14 (87) R. Terry 1B: 22 (97) D. Donovan 2B: 6 (54) B. Daniels 3B: 1 (1) S. Lyle HR: 12 (87) R. Terry RBI: 26 (87) R. Terry BB: 18 (124) C. Pascual SO: 20 (98) B. Pierce HBP: 2 (30) M. Fornieles	H: 0 (13) J. Santiago XBH: 0 (34) H. Aguirre 1B: 0 (23) F. Talbot 2B: 0 (82) D. Chance 3B: 0 (124) C. Pascual HR: 0 (52) H. Brown RBI: 0 (34) H. Aguirre BB: 0 (34) F. Newman SO: 0 (35) W. Bunker HBP: 0 (113) P. Ramos	1.436 (31) H. Griggs 1.381 (32) P. Richert 1.286 (53) D. Stigman 1.282 (45) T. Clevenger 1.273 (67) B. Latman 1.265 (31) D. Morehead 1.243 (54) B. Daniels 1.241 (50) B. Daley 1.215 (56) G. Bell 1.188 (42) D. Sisler	0.588 (34) F. Newman 0.583 (35) W. Bunker 0.566 (41) M. Lolich 0.553 (51) B. Stafford 0.509 (34) R. Roberts 0.495 (35) D. Radatz 0.494 (42) D. Maas 0.343 (30) P. Ortega 0.303 (37) D. McLain 0.180 (34) H. Aguirre

Jim Davenport (1958-1970)
Racked	Skunked	High OPS	Low OPS
H: 27 (127) D. Drysdale XBH: 8 (76) J. O'Toole 1B: 21 (127) D. Drysdale 2B: 5 (57) B. Gibson 3B: 2 (24) D. Giusti HR: 4 (46) R. Craig RBI: 12 (46) R. Craig BB: 9 (73) S. Koufax SO: 30 (127) D. Drysdale HBP: 3 (8) B. Muffett	H: 0 (17) C. Raydon XBH: 0 (40) J. Bunning 1B: 0 (17) C. Raydon 2B: 0 (56) K. Johnson 3B: 0 (127) D. Drysdale HR: 0 (86) L. Jackson RBI: 0 (28) D. Green BB: 0 (40) J. Bunning SO: 0 (21) R. Semproch HBP: 0 (102) W. Spahn	1.086 (32) R. Culp 1.050 (46) R. Craig 1.029 (35) B. Miller 0.997 (55) V. Mizell 0.967 (76) J. O'Toole 0.919 (54) R. Sadecki 0.915 (35) A. Jackson 0.899 (47) C. Short 0.896 (49) G. Hobbie 0.880 (73) S. Koufax	0.512 (72) B. Purkey 0.484 (49) T. Farrell 0.470 (41) A. Mahaffey 0.466 (37) N. Briles 0.419 (39) D. Drott 0.418 (33) T. Cloninger 0.411 (39) D. Elston 0.361 (35) R. Face 0.342 (39) R. Roberts 0.156 (40) J. Bunning

Tito Francona (1956-1970)
Racked	Skunked	High OPS	Low OPS
H: 32 (115) J. Bunning XBH: 11 (115) J. Bunning 1B: 21 (115) J. Bunning 2B: 7 (26) D. Wickersham 3B: 1 (4) P. Charton 3B: 1 (4) J. Gibbon 3B: 1 (4) E. Kinder 3B: 1 (4) B. Sadowski HR: 5 (115) J. Bunning RBI: 17 (115) J. Bunning BB: 12 (48) D. Larsen SO: 21 (81) C. Pascual HBP: 3 (92) F. Lary	H: 0 (18) D. Morehead XBH: 0 (33) B. Hoeft 1B: 0 (18) D. Morehead 2B: 0 (42) J. Marichal 3B: 0 (115) J. Bunning HR: 0 (62) P. Ramos RBI: 0 (40) B. Pierce BB: 0 (40) D. Donovan SO: 0 (36) K. McBride HBP: 0 (102) M. Pappas	1.328 (36) J. Coates 1.238 (38) N. Garver 1.129 (42) B. Turley 1.042 (55) B. Shaw 1.035 (36) D. Segui 1.032 (69) P. Foytack 0.939 (30) D. Cardwell 0.895 (31) H. Wilhelm 0.885 (52) B. Fischer 0.866 (35) D. Sisler	0.567 (35) T. Sturdivant 0.528 (49) T. Brewer 0.522 (53) H. Brown 0.501 (53) A. Ditmar 0.493 (33) J. Kaat 0.492 (32) J. Pizarro 0.486 (67) J. Fisher 0.472 (31) B. Singer 0.455 (67) W. Ford 0.416 (33) B. Hoeft

Ken Johnson (1958-1970)
Racked	Skunked	High OPS	Low OPS
H: 25 (81) T. Haller XBH: 11 (76) E. Banks 1B: 21 (81) T. Haller 2B: 6 (76) E. Banks 3B: 2 (8) J. Becquer HR: 5 (69) J. Hart RBI: 16 (76) E. Banks BB: 17 (91) W. McCovey SO: 19 (91) R. Santo HBP: 5 (66) T. Taylor	H: 0 (11) E. Battey XBH: 0 (37) E. Mathews 1B: 0 (17) B. Gibson 2B: 0 (91) R. Santo 3B: 0 (91) W. McCovey 3B: 0 (91) R. Santo HR: 0 (63) M. Wills RBI: 0 (49) G. Beckert BB: 0 (75) C. Flood SO: 0 (38) C. Hiller HBP: 0 (91) J. Callison HBP: 0 (91) B. Williams	1.187 (35) H. Aaron 1.089 (34) W. Stargell 1.080 (43) B. Skinner 1.067 (35) E. Kranepool 1.055 (55) D. Allen 0.977 (32) A. Phillips 0.969 (43) F. Robinson 0.952 (91) W. McCovey 0.945 (43) T. Harper 0.934 (52) J. Edwards	0.514 (75) C. Flood 0.506 (54) J. Javier 0.482 (37) E. Mathews 0.481 (54) R. Clemente 0.475 (30) D. Maxvill 0.459 (49) H. Lanier 0.441 (30) R. Hundley 0.372 (30) R. Sievers 0.371 (49) G. Beckert 0.340 (32) J. Briggs

Johnny Kucks (1955-1960)
Racked	Skunked	High OPS	Low OPS
H: 22 (50) G. Woodling XBH: 8 (70) A. Smith 1B: 19 (50) G. Woodling 2B: 4 (63) H. Lopez 3B: 2 (21) E. Battey HR: 4 (57) E. Yost RBI: 13 (50) G. Woodling BB: 10 (55) C. Maxwell SO: 9 (70) A. Smith HBP: 4 (57) E. Yost	H: 0 (15) F. Lary XBH: 0 (35) J. DeMaestri 1B: 0 (15) F. Lary 2B: 0 (57) E. Yost 3B: 0 (70) A. Smith HR: 0 (64) V. Power RBI: 0 (36) B. Goodman BB: 0 (34) F. Malzone SO: 0 (50) G. Woodling HBP: 0 (70) A. Smith	1.229 (50) G. Woodling 1.180 (34) H. Simpson 1.109 (49) J. Lemon 1.025 (60) A. Kaline 1.008 (37) R. Nixon 0.967 (41) F. Bolling 0.952 (36) B. Goodman 0.941 (55) C. Maxwell 0.924 (51) R. Sievers 0.892 (36) R. Maris	0.603 (53) B. Avila 0.603 (34) A. Rosen 0.600 (31) G. Stephens 0.586 (42) S. Lollar 0.562 (42) C. Courtney 0.531 (30) J. Landis 0.494 (39) E. Torgeson 0.412 (34) F. Malzone 0.394 (35) J. DeMaestri 0.343 (39) A. Pilarcik

Jerry Lumpe (1956-1967)
Racked	Skunked	High OPS	Low OPS
H: 28 (102) M. Pappas XBH: 7 (64) G. Bell 1B: 24 (102) M. Pappas 2B: 5 (64) G. Bell 3B: 2 (11) J. Spring HR: 4 (85) R. Terry RBI: 11 (116) C. Pascual BB: 10 (84) B. Monbouquette SO: 16 (116) C. Pascual HBP: 1 (7) S. Ridzik	H: 0 (15) G. Staley H: 0 (15) F. Talbot XBH: 0 (51) R. Herbert 1B: 0 (23) R. Narleski 2B: 0 (85) R. Terry 3B: 0 (116) C. Pascual HR: 0 (102) M. Pappas RBI: 0 (42) J. Bouton BB: 0 (53) D. Mossi SO: 0 (57) B. Latman HBP: 0 (102) M. Pappas	1.068 (36) R. Sheldon 1.066 (35) D. Lee 0.998 (64) J. Bunning 0.935 (30) D. Segui 0.906 (33) T. Clevenger 0.888 (64) G. Bell 0.880 (33) H. Brown 0.856 (46) D. Donovan 0.806 (57) B. Latman 0.800 (33) W. Bunker	0.485 (39) C. Estrada 0.481 (52) J. Kaat 0.475 (30) F. Newman 0.472 (49) R. Roberts 0.471 (44) B. Daniels 0.461 (33) F. Sullivan 0.416 (51) R. Herbert 0.353 (38) A. Downing 0.346 (39) L. Stange 0.153 (42) J. Bouton

Billy O'Dell (1954-1967)
Racked	Skunked	High OPS	Low OPS
H: 27 (82) D. Groat XBH: 8 (64) V. Pinson 1B: 22 (82) D. Groat 2B: 6 (64) V. Pinson 3B: 3 (35) B. Tuttle HR: 4 (39) F. Howard RBI: 14 (78) R. Santo BB: 11 (76) E. Banks SO: 20 (74) T. Taylor HBP: 4 (86) N. Fox	H: 0 (15) B. Buhl XBH: 0 (67) R. Sievers 1B: 0 (17) D. Buddin 2B: 0 (67) R. Sievers 3B: 0 (83) B. White HR: 0 (86) N. Fox RBI: 0 (45) B. Aspromonte BB: 0 (41) B. Virdon SO: 0 (29) C. Carrasquel HBP: 0 (83) B. White	1.150 (40) H. Aaron 1.144 (41) F. Robinson 1.045 (33) D. Allen 1.043 (39) F. Howard 1.007 (42) F. Thomas 1.005 (30) P. Rose 0.989 (57) T. Davis 0.967 (35) B. Tuttle 0.938 (30) J. Jensen 0.900 (45) C. James	0.448 (47) T. Gonzalez 0.424 (37) D. Stuart 0.406 (40) J. Lemon 0.391 (32) B. Skinner 0.390 (45) B. Aspromonte 0.390 (41) B. Virdon 0.382 (41) M. Minoso 0.350 (45) R. Fairly 0.329 (40) C. Rojas 0.310 (31) C. Dalrymple

Orlando Pena (1958-1975)
Racked	Skunked	High OPS	Low OPS
H: 18 (51) J. Fregosi XBH: 8 (51) J. Fregosi 1B: 11 (28) E. Howard 2B: 6 (51) J. Fregosi 3B: 2 (14) J. Foy 3B: 2 (14) R. Repoz HR: 4 (32) D. Lock RBI: 9 (36) D. McAuliffe BB: 11 (40) C. Yastrzemski SO: 12 (26) J. Brandt HBP: 2 (15) B. Johnson	H: 0 (12) D. McNally XBH: 0 (33) V. Davalillo 1B: 0 (21) J. Hall 2B: 0 (33) V. Davalillo 3B: 0 (44) B. Robinson HR: 0 (40) B. Bruton RBI: 0 (32) E. Bressoud RBI: 0 (32) B. Moran BB: 0 (32) J. Adair SO: 0 (39) A. Pearson HBP: 0 (44) B. Robinson	1.359 (40) C. Yastrzemski 1.165 (36) D. McAuliffe 1.153 (32) D. Lock 1.097 (41) Z. Versalles 1.081 (51) J. Fregosi 1.046 (39) B. Powell 1.026 (38) H. Killebrew 1.021 (39) T. Tresh 1.014 (44) B. Robinson 0.992 (41) L. Thomas	0.722 (39) A. Pearson 0.688 (32) J. Adair 0.685 (41) B. Rodgers 0.659 (42) L. Wagner 0.643 (31) B. Allison 0.556 (38) W. Kirkland 0.522 (31) L. Green 0.499 (32) E. Bressoud 0.365 (30) M. Hershberger 0.343 (30) D. Stuart

John Roseboro (1957-1970)
Racked	Skunked	High OPS	Low OPS
H: 33 (142) L. Jackson XBH: 9 (142) L. Jackson 1B: 24 (142) L. Jackson 2B: 7 (142) L. Jackson 3B: 3 (38) R. Kline HR: 3 (40) C. Willey RBI: 12 (54) B. Bruce BB: 18 (91) B. Gibson SO: 18 (100) J. Jay HBP: 3 (47) J. Bunning	H: 0 (18) J. Nuxhall XBH: 0 (39) D. Ellsworth 1B: 0 (18) J. Nuxhall 2B: 0 (100) J. Jay 3B: 0 (142) L. Jackson HR: 0 (71) T. Farrell RBI: 0 (67) E. Broglio BB: 0 (36) R. Craig SO: 0 (30) C. Koonce HBP: 0 (99) J. Marichal	1.025 (38) R. Kline 1.017 (32) T. Stallard 1.000 (54) B. Bruce 0.964 (31) T. Cloninger 0.908 (48) B. Anderson 0.899 (33) S. Miller 0.895 (40) C. Willey 0.864 (34) D. Nottebart 0.861 (91) B. Gibson 0.861 (41) R. Face	0.554 (64) R. Roberts 0.551 (39) D. Ellsworth 0.509 (34) M. Drabowsky 0.483 (67) E. Broglio 0.475 (40) C. Short 0.473 (37) D. McLain 0.451 (42) B. Shaw 0.407 (35) C. Simmons 0.389 (36) R. Craig 0.378 (99) J. Marichal

Herb Score (1955-1962)
Racked	Skunked	High OPS	Low OPS
H: 24 (63) H. Lopez XBH: 9 (63) H. Lopez 1B: 15 (63) H. Lopez 2B: 4 (48) V. Power 3B: 2 (48) E. Howard HR: 5 (63) H. Lopez RBI: 17 (63) H. Lopez BB: 17 (58) E. Yost SO: 13 (44) J. Lemon HBP: 1 (4) R. Jackson	H: 0 (15) K. Olson XBH: 0 (43) R. Wilson 1B: 0 (29) B. Klaus 2B: 0 (58) E. Yost 3B: 0 (79) B. Tuttle HR: 0 (62) H. Kuenn RBI: 0 (39) R. Bertoia BB: 0 (21) C. Boyer SO: 0 (24) B. Robinson HBP: 0 (79) B. Tuttle	1.231 (63) H. Lopez 1.201 (34) T. Williams 1.005 (32) J. Piersall 0.956 (47) G. Zernial 0.904 (43) J. Jensen 0.894 (67) A. Kaline 0.869 (44) J. Lemon 0.859 (53) M. Mantle 0.858 (48) P. Runnels 0.826 (46) W. Dropo	0.508 (39) J. Busby 0.499 (52) N. Fox 0.488 (46) S. Lollar 0.482 (38) F. Bolling 0.479 (35) M. Minoso 0.467 (39) L. Aparicio 0.433 (41) J. DeMaestri 0.393 (43) R. Wilson 0.378 (39) R. Bertoia 0.326 (38) J. Finigan

Bob Shaw (1957-1967)
Racked	Skunked	High OPS	Low OPS
H: 22 (52) R. Clemente XBH: 7 (54) R. Maris 1B: 18 (52) R. Clemente 2B: 5 (54) R. Maris 3B: 2 (52) V. Pinson HR: 4 (33) J. Gentile RBI: 14 (55) T. Francona BB: 12 (47) M. Mantle SO: 14 (46) J. Javier HBP: 4 (40) O. Cepeda	H: 0 (19) S. Boros XBH: 0 (38) H. Smith 1B: 0 (23) J. Briggs 2B: 0 (51) B. White 3B: 0 (65) L. Brock HR: 0 (65) L. Brock RBI: 0 (45) R. Fairly BB: 0 (52) D. Groat SO: 0 (41) A. Kaline HBP: 0 (65) L. Brock	1.207 (41) A. Kaline 1.194 (33) J. Gentile 1.076 (32) T. Gonzalez 1.072 (52) R. Clemente 1.070 (40) J. Edwards 1.063 (52) V. Pinson 1.049 (52) J. Lemon 1.045 (35) M. Keough 1.042 (55) T. Francona 1.040 (40) G. Woodling	0.562 (58) M. Wills 0.537 (40) M. Throneberry 0.532 (31) G. Alley 0.530 (31) C. Maxwell 0.518 (46) J. Javier 0.493 (35) J. Lumpe 0.469 (38) H. Smith 0.451 (42) J. Roseboro 0.442 (45) R. Fairly 0.439 (42) T. Kubek

Norm Siebern (1956-1968)
Racked	Skunked	High OPS	Low OPS
H: 25 (78) R. Terry XBH: 15 (78) R. Terry 1B: 18 (94) F. Lary 2B: 7 (63) B. Monbouquette 3B: 4 (78) R. Terry HR: 5 (34) H. Brown RBI: 15 (78) R. Terry BB: 14 (87) M. Grant SO: 32 (125) C. Pascual HBP: 1 (3) K. Lehman	H: 0 (13) J. Bonikowski H: 0 (13) J. O'Donoghue XBH: 0 (37) P. Burnside 1B: 0 (16) T. Sturdivant 2B: 0 (68) E. Wynn 3B: 0 (94) F. Lary HR: 0 (66) S. Barber RBI: 0 (29) D. Radatz BB: 0 (23) C. Stobbs SO: 0 (28) J. Lamabe HBP: 0 (125) C. Pascual	1.192 (34) H. Brown 1.166 (39) R. Kemmerer 1.117 (63) B. Monbouquette 1.112 (78) R. Terry 1.100 (45) T. Brewer 1.036 (32) R. Sheldon 1.034 (53) B. Daniels 1.032 (44) D. Chance 0.993 (30) J. Harshman 0.981 (61) E. Wilson	0.555 (30) A. Downing 0.546 (65) H. Wilhelm 0.533 (53) B. Latman 0.530 (63) W. Ford 0.506 (66) S. Barber 0.476 (36) C. Osteen 0.459 (65) D. Donovan 0.405 (63) M. Pappas 0.372 (31) G. Peters 0.337 (37) P. Burnside

Plate appearances shown in parentheses.
Racked: Against which opponent did this player rack up the highest total in the indicated category? Ties are broken in order of fewest plate appearances.
Skunked: Which opponent did this player face the most times without ever registering in the indicated category?
High or Low OPS: Against which 10 opponents did this player compile the highest (or lowest) sum of on-base percentage and slugging average, with a minimum of 30 plate appearances?
Players are included if they totaled at least 3500 plate appearances or batters faced during the seasons listed below.
Includes all games played between 1974 and 2010, and almost all games played between 1950 and 1973. Can you help? The figures shown may not reflect the entire career of either the batter or the pitcher. In all probability, the rankings will change as additional games and seasons are released by Retrosheet. This page is presented for entertainment purposes only. Excruciating Baseball Lists accepts no responsibility for any disputes which may arise in response to any trivia questions posed based on information listed hereon.
The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at "www.retrosheet.org".